Peer Review Policy
1. Scope of Peer Review
1.1. Academic contributions intended for the journal’s main “Topic” section are generally subject to the standard anonymous peer review process. These are original contributions presenting the results or partial results of original research, usually focused on a single topic, which have not previously been published in another printed periodical or online.
1.2. Contributions to the journal’s other regular sections are subject to a simplified peer review process, unless the Editorial Board reserves the right to subject a contribution to the standard peer review process.
1.3. Authors are responsible for the content of their contributions. Contributions published in the journal Czech Environmental Law do not necessarily reflect the views of the Editorial Team or the Editorial Board.
1.4. A contribution may also be rejected for publication if the submitted manuscript has already been published in another Czech periodical or online.
2. Procedure Before Peer Review
2.1. The Editorial Team, through the Editor-in-Chief, receives contributions submitted for publication in the journal.
2.2. The Editorial Board may at any time request manuscripts submitted to the Editorial Team for inspection or assessment, including those not normally intended for peer review, such as notices of significant birthdays or forthcoming academic conferences.
2.3. The Editorial Team may reject a submitted contribution if it considers that the contribution does not meet the basic requirements for an academic text or falls substantially outside the field of environmental law and related disciplines. The Editorial Team must explain its decision to the Editorial Board if the Editorial Board requests it to do so.
2.4. The Editorial Team may recommend that the author make linguistic, formal or substantive changes before the submitted manuscript is sent for standard or simplified peer review. If the author declines to make the proposed changes, the Editorial Team shall send the contribution as submitted by the author for standard or simplified peer review.
3. Peer Review Process
3.1. The Editorial Team assesses every contribution submitted to the journal to determine whether it is intended for the “Topic” section. The Editorial Board may reserve the right to make this assessment. Such contributions are subject to the standard anonymous peer review process. The Editor-in-Chief informs the author whether the contribution has been accepted for standard or simplified peer review and subsequently informs them of the outcome.
3.2. In the standard anonymous peer review process, a contribution is assessed by two reviewers, generally selected from among the members of the Editorial Board or from a pool of experts recommended by a member of the Editorial Board or, if it reserves this right, by the Editorial Board itself.
3.3. The author and the reviewers remain anonymous to one another. A reviewer must not be employed at the same institution as the author or any of the co-authors and must not have any other conflict of interest concerning the contribution under review.
3.4. A reviewer who has agreed to assess a submitted manuscript will normally review it within four weeks and prepare an expert review report. The report must conclude with a recommendation that the Editorial Team a) accept the contribution for publication without changes, b) accept it with changes, c) require it to be substantially revised, or d) reject it for publication. Reasons must be given in every case.
3.5. On the basis of the reviewers’ reports, the Editor-in-Chief informs the author whether the Editorial Team a) accepts the manuscript for publication without reservations, b) requires substantial revision of the manuscript, c) requires changes to the manuscript, or d) declines to accept the manuscript for publication. If substantial revision or changes are requested, or the manuscript is rejected, the Editor-in-Chief also provides the principal reasons. In all cases, the final decision to accept or reject a contribution is made by the Editor-in-Chief or, if it reserves this right, the Editorial Board.
3.6. The outcome of the standard anonymous peer review process is binding on the author of the submitted contribution, who must address the reviewers’ comments by the deadline set by the Editor-in-Chief, unless point 3.7 provides otherwise. If the author fails to revise the contribution or makes insufficient changes, the Editorial Team or the Editorial Board reserves the right to refuse to publish it.
3.7. If the author disagrees with a reviewer’s report, they may send the Editorial Team a letter or email explaining the reasons for their disagreement. The Editor-in-Chief shall submit it to the relevant reviewers for their opinion and communicate that opinion to the author. If the reviewers and the author do not reach agreement, the Editor-in-Chief shall decide whether to publish the contribution or submit the author’s text to the Editorial Board for a final decision if the Board has reserved that decision.
3.8. An examiner’s report is also considered a review report where the publication concerns a thesis submitted for a qualification, or a substantial part of such a thesis, which has been defended at a higher education institution. A review report is not required for the publication of texts of academic lectures delivered before the academic board of the relevant higher education institution or its faculty as part of a habilitation or professorial appointment procedure.
3.9. The provisions governing the standard peer review process apply, as appropriate, to the simplified peer review process, except that one review report by a member of the Editorial Board is sufficient.
4. Editorial Board
The Editorial Board consists of distinguished experts in environmental law and related disciplines. Members of the Editorial Board are appointed by the Board of the Czech Society for Environmental Law. The Editorial Board adopts decisions by a majority of its members.
5. Final Provision
This policy and any amendments to it are approved by the Board of the Czech Society for Environmental Law pursuant to Article 12 of its Statutes.