Opens in a new tab

Plans and Projects Subject Only to Notification Cannot Be Exempted from Appropriate Assessment as a General Rule

In its judgment of 22 October 2026 in Case C-548/25, Dryade, the Court of Justice of the European Union answered a question referred for a preliminary ruling by the Belgian Raad voor Vergunningsbetwistingen (Council for Permit Disputes) concerning the interpretation of Article 6(3) of Council Directive 92/43/EEC (the Habitats Directive). The central issue was whether certain categories of plans and projects could be systematically exempted from the requirement to carry out an appropriate assessment under the Habitats Directive on the basis of predetermined criteria and thresholds.

The dispute concerned a groundwater abstraction project involving the extraction of water from a depth of 60 metres, with a maximum abstraction rate of 175 m³ per day and 5,000 m³ per year, situated approximately 425 metres from a special area of conservation. Under Flemish legislation, such abstraction falls within Class 3 and is therefore subject only to a notification requirement. The obligation to carry out an appropriate assessment, however, applied only to activities requiring a permit. The City of Peer acknowledged receipt of the notification, while the claimant environmental organisation argued that the project should have undergone an appropriate assessment, that the criterion based on a radius within which the groundwater level would fall by 1 cm lacked a scientific basis, and that the cumulative effects of four other groundwater abstractions in the vicinity had not been taken into account.

The Court recalled the two-stage structure of Article 6(3) of the Habitats Directive: the first stage requires an appropriate assessment where a plan or project is likely to have a significant effect on a protected site, while the second permits its authorisation only where it will not adversely affect the integrity of that site. Referring to the precautionary principle, the Court reiterated that a risk of significant effects exists where such effects cannot be excluded on the basis of the best scientific knowledge in the field, and that Article 6(3) generally requires an individual assessment of plans and projects.

The central issue in the judgment was the permissibility of general exemptions. Referring to its previous case law, particularly Commission v Belgium, C-538/09, the Court confirmed that a Member State cannot, in principle, systematically and generally exempt certain categories of plans or projects from the assessment requirement on the basis of their sector of activity or by introducing a notification procedure. Such a regime is permissible only by way of exception, provided that national legislation makes it possible to exclude with certainty, on the basis of objective information, any likelihood that a plan or project subject to that regime will have a significant effect on a protected site, either individually or in combination with other plans or projects.

According to the Court, the Flemish legislation did not satisfy this condition. First, even a small-scale project may have significant effects if it is situated in a sensitive environment. In the specific context of water use, the Court had already held that the abstraction of small quantities of water does not, in itself, exclude the possibility of significant effects on a neighbouring protected site. A Member State therefore cannot assume that categories defined by reference to the sector of activity and the scale of a project will, by their very nature, have only insignificant effects. Secondly, the criteria and thresholds adopted referred solely to the characteristics of the project concerned and did not allow other plans and projects within or near the protected site, or their cumulative effects, to be taken into account. Yet Article 6(3) expressly applies to plans and projects likely to have significant effects ‘in combination with other plans or projects’.

The Court therefore concluded that Article 6(3) of the Habitats Directive precludes national legislation which exempts certain categories of plans or projects from the requirement to carry out an appropriate assessment on the basis of predetermined criteria and thresholds, where those criteria and thresholds do not make it possible to exclude with certainty, on the basis of objective information, the likelihood that such plans or projects will have a significant effect on a special area of conservation, either individually or in combination with other plans or projects.

The judgment of the Court of Justice of 22 October 2026, Dryade, C-548/25, is available here.

Previous page