Opens in a new tab

Year 2025

Number 2

Ochrana přírody a životního prostředí jako limit výkonu občanských práv z pohledu rozhodovací praxe Nejvyššího soudu

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND NATURE CONSERVATION AS A LIMIT TO THE EXERCISE OF CIVIL RIGHTS FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE SUPREME COURT‘S CASE LAW
The article examines how environmental protection and nature conservation can influence the exercise of civil rights in line with Supreme Court case law. Civil law, based on autonomy of will and independence from public law, nonetheless intersects with constitutionally protected values and public law regulations. The text emphasizes the role of constitutionally protected values as interpretative guidelines, as well as the general imperatives of good morals protection and the prohibition of abuse of rights as means of incorporating environmental values into private law relations. Case law shows that although explicit provisions on these values in the Civil Code are limited (e.g., tree-felling rules), the Supreme Court takes nature and its constitutional protection into account when interpreting indeterminate provisions such as neighbour rights, prevention of impending harm, or the mentioned correctives of good morals and prohibition of abuse of rights. The article also points out that public law rules may in certain cases limit the exercise of civil rights, particularly when these arguments are actively raised by the parties. It further highlights the growing societal preference for environmental protection, which influences the interpretation of private law norms. In conclusion, it states that although environmental values lie outside the core of civil law, they have the potential to act as correctives in the exercise of rights, reinforcing the balance between individual interests and the protection of public goods.

Keywords
civil law, environmental and nature protection, legal interpretation

Page range:

95-109

Article type:

Scholarly Articles

Language:

DOI:

Previous page