Opens in a new tab

Year 2025

Number 3

Ústavní soud k právu na informace o životním prostředí a požadavku přiměřenosti výše úhrady za poskytnutí takových informací

CONSTITUTIONAL COURT ON THE RIGHT TO ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION AND THE REQUIREMENT OF REASONABLENESS OF THE AMOUNT OF PAYMENT FOR THE PROVISION OF SUCH INFORMATION
The paper deals with the judgment of the Constitutional Court of 26 June 2024, file no. I. ÚS 3254/22, regarding right to environmental information. According to the Czech Constitutional Court, the amount of 2,998,037 CZK that the Land Survey Office demanded from the complainant for the provision of a digital relief model of the Czech Republic constitutes a restriction of his fundamental right to environmental information. The restriction of the complainant’s right to environmental information is based on a statutory regulation that generally pursues the legitimate aim of ensuring the functioning of public administration, namely through partial financing of indirect costs of state authorities for the creation and updating of a digital relief model of the Czech Republic by entities using spatial data for private commercial purposes. However, the restriction of the complainant‘s right – a data journalist – to environmental information is unconstitutional, as the requested amount constitutes an economic barrier that appears to be objectively disproportionate (hardly surmountable) in relation to the complainant and in connection with the public interest in environmental protection. The fundamental right to environmental information under Article 35(2) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms may be made subject to payment for the provision of such information by law if the amount requested is reasonable. The assessment of reasonableness must always be based on the specific circumstances of the case and take into account both subjective aspects, i.e. the position of the applicant for environmental information and the purpose for which the information is requested, and objective aspects, i.e. the nature of the environmental information requested and the potential dissuasive effect of the amount requested on persons in a similar position to the applicant.

Keywords
environment, right to environmental information, payment, case law, Constitutional Court

Page range:

149-166

Article type:

Caselaw

Language:

DOI:

Previous page